Home > Holodomor | Ukrainophobia | Demjanjuk | d&d (Furman, Odynsky, Katriuk) | Zuzak Letters |

Kyiv Post | 17Jun2013 | Askold Lozynskyj

'Journalistic sensationalism' when reporting on commander of Nazi-led unit

Dear Editors:

It is regrettable that a venerable and longstanding institution such as yours would take up journalistic sensationalism without regard to historical accuracy or verification. You advocate persecuting a 94 year old American citizen on hearsay taken from alleged witnesses that are not available for examination and whose veracity is not only questionable, but whose testimony is entirely irrelevant since it does not specifically damn your accused, rather a unit which he allegedly commanded. The Ukrainian Self Defense Legion has never been under suspicion at any level. The SS Galician Division has been the subject of inquiries for almost 70 years. The result of those inquiries is that it has been found not guilty of war crimes. 

I could cite hundreds of sources. Suffice it to cite two, one an allegedly objective and certainly not pro-Ukrainian historian from Yale University, Timothy Snyder: "The SS-Galizien was not used for any major actions against the Jews, because the Final Solution had already been carried out...the SS-Galizien was marginal to the outbreak of ethnic cleansing against Poles".

In 1986 a Canadian Commission of Inquiry on War Crimes ruled: " The Commission of Inquiry on War Crimes was established in February 1985 in Canada, with the purpose of exposing and prosecuting war criminals residing in Canada. The Simon Wiesenthal Center and other Jewish groups in Canada have repeatedly denounced the Ukrainian Division Galicia as a perpetrator of war crimes...Although Communist propaganda has constantly attempted to depict these, like so many other refugees, as "quislings" and "war criminals" it is interesting to note that no specific charges of war crimes have been made by the Soviet or any other government against any member of this group....Charges of war crimes of Galicia Division have never been substantiated, either in 1950 when they were first preferred, or in 1984 when they were renewed, or before this Commission..." Canada and the United States were allies during World War 2, at the time of Mr. Karkoc's immigration and remain so today.

You may have stumbled upon criminality, however, not that of Mr. Karkoc. He may have withheld specific information about his whereabouts during the war at the time of immigration. Many did. Why? Because the United States acting through President Franklin Roosevelt, either a Stalin dupe or a Soviet "quisling" influenced by Soviet agents in the U.S. Department of State such as Alger Hiss, at the Yalta Conference in February 1945 sold out to Stalin and the Soviets, agreeing to enslave Eastern Europe and to send its refugees to their death through repatriation. This policy resulted in the murder of millions innocent men, women and children. The criminality is ours as Americans. This criminality even today merits attention, condemnation, remorse and an apology. Your readers would be better served exploring that, rather than persecuting a 94 year old Minnesotan whose only fault was trying to protect his loved ones.

On this Father's day, I recall my own father. He entered this country with my mother and my one-year old sister in 1951. He was a member of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists. Like the Galician Division, the OUN was on an inimical list compiled by the International Refugee Organization with Soviet assistance. My father did not reveal his OUN membership. Upon his entry, someone alerted government officials. He was sequestered for several months on Ellis Island. Finally the U.S. Government realized that their erstwhile allies, the Soviets with whom they were now in a Cold War, had placed all anti-Soviet formations on the list. My father was allowed entry and subsequent naturalization. It took some time but at last the United States came to realize that President Roosevelt's friend Uncle Josef Stalin was responsible for more murders than the Nazis.

The Soviet Union is officially in demise, but Russia, very much alive today, carries on its legacy and politics. Americans were Soviet dupes too often in the past. Why do you insist on reprising that role?

June 16, 2013                                            Askold S. Lozynskyj

New York, New York 10003

Askold S. Lozynskyj is an attorney, former president of the Ukrainian World Congress and has served as an international election observer in Ukraine since 1990, including the Oct 28, 2012 parliamentary election.


Roman Zacharkiw:  17Jun2013 at 5:15 am
Your words are true Askold. I add one little comment and ask one question to the editors and readers of Kyiv post.How many people have been arrested, invesrtigated or convicted for war crimes against the people of Ukraine? Answer, a big fat zero. How many people have been arrested, investigated or convicted for crimes against Ukrainian people under the soviet rule? Answer, a big fat zero. How many have been conviected for the biggest genocide in world history against Ukraine by creating the famine of 1923/1933. Yes we know the answer , a big fat zero. Russia has the bare face insult still not to recognise it as a genocide. Why 3 big fat zero's. I ask the editor to please explain why. Also I ask the editor to pleas put these questions forward to the President and Prime minister of Ukraine. Why have they not persued justice for the Ukrainians who perished and were slaughtered, prior , durring and after the second world war. Millions of Ukrainian lives were taken , not in acts of war but in acts of barbarism.
roman zacharkiw

Andy Holowaty: 17Jun2013 at 9:08 am
Kudos to Askold for taking the lead in setting the record straight!

Still bruised from the beating of injustice suffered during the Demjanjuk fiasco, Ukrainians are being bullied once more -- and the harassment will probably not end here if this sham also goes to kangaroo court.

The global Ukrainian community is being provoked yet again in an ugly and sociopathic manner to defend its honour and history. After doing away with John Demjanjuk in an unjust and callous manner, the "Remember Our Pain - At Any Cost" Industry -- which has dubious and diabolical support in the Kremlin -- has launched its next propaganda campaign by targeting another Ukrainian WWII veteran from the complex fog of war of the 1940s, which took place on and around embattled Ukrainian lands.

Michael Karkoc has become this Industry's next victim: a convenient scapegoat, constructed from disinformation and lies to serve the perpetual and perverted needs of this Industry, well known for its fundamental anti-Ukrainian positions. Aided by the power and reach of the Associated Press, the Industry's propaganda campaign of disinformation and defamation is again under way in full force.

I call upon Kyiv Post and other journalistic entities to do the responsible thing and follow the lead of credible and authoritative historians and academics who tell a COMPREHENSIVE & OBJECTIVE account of the bigger picture of World War II, not limiting it to only remembering the tragedy of the Holocaust or a self-serving Soviet Great Patriotic War.

Elmer Mack: 17Jun2013 at 7:58 am
Askold, your article is right on point.

This is not mere sensationalism -- this is journalistic dishonesty.

It starts with the supposed discovery of a "top Nazi leader," and goes from there, in large part based on specifically crafted implications.

As a preliminary check, all that the "journalists" had to do was to check Wikipedia for a bit of background, which quotes Yale historian Timothy Snyder and other authoritative sources:


Wächter approached the Ukrainian Central Committee, a nonpolitical social welfare organization headed by Volodymyr Kubiyovych which supported the idea of the formation of the division[10] The Ukrainian Catholic Church demanded the presence of its chaplains in the division, which was usually not permitted by Germans. Thus the Ukrainian division along with the Bosnian one became notable exceptions.

Germans made two political concessions: It was stipulated that the division shall not be used to fight Western Allies, and would be used exclusively to "fight Bolsheviks". The other concession was in that its oath of allegiance to Hitler was conditional[citation needed] on the fight against Bolshevism and in the fact that Christian (mostly Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church and Ukrainian Orthodox) chaplains were integrated into the units and allowed to function (in the Waffen-SS, only the Bosnian division and Sturmbrigade Wallonien had a clerical presence). The latter condition was instituted at the insistence of the division's organizers in order to minimize the risk of Nazi demoralization amongst the soldiers.[11][page needed] Indeed, Nazi indoctrination was absent within the division.[12].

The creation of foreign SS units had been carried out previously in the name of fighting against communism; with French, Dutch, Latvian, Estonian, Croatian, and Belarusian units, among others, had been created.[13] The creation of a Ukrainian SS division was perceived by many in Ukraine as a step towards the attainment of Ukrainian independence and attracted many volunteers.

NOTE: Nazi indoctrination was absent within the division.

The media feeding frenzy about Karkos is based on journalistic dishonesty and should not be tolerated.

Thank you for your letter, Askold Lozynsky, and thanks to the Kyiv Post for posting it.

Dirk Smith: 17Jun2013 at 8:05 pm
When you are incapable of creating jobs and your cover-ups continue to mount, you can always count on a Nazi story from Obama's Pravda boot-lickers to deflect from your growing inadequacies. This corrupt cabal currently in the WH makes Putin look credible. D-U-E P-R-O-C-E-S-S. Brilliant letter, Askold.

Steve Patriarca: 19Jun2013 at12:19 am
Excellent letter and thank you for letting us read it without charge! It is important for all Eastern Europe that the west gains a better understanding of the relationship between the nationalists and the Nazis. As you all know, not everyone who suported the Nazis was a Nazi: in Central and Eastern Europe the last war was between two tyrannies. Some people are only prosecuted for supporting one of them because they happened to be on the losing side.

Jakub Parusinski · Chief Editor at Kyiv Post: 20Jun2013 at ???
All letters to the editor are posted outside the Kyiv Post paywall, as with other opinion pieces. We encourage everyone to share their views, so as to foster discussion and debate. The paywall covers only exclusive Kyiv Post reporting and stories/services that we pay for.

Regarding the Askold's letter, its a powerful and well-argumented read. We hope to see more.


CBC News | 14Jun2013 | Associated Press

Former commander in Nazi-led unit found living in Minnesota

Michael Karkoc, 94, told authorities in 1949 he had performed no military service

A top commander of a Nazi SS-led unit accused of burning villages filled with women and children lied to American immigration officials to get into the United States and has been living in Minnesota since shortly after the Second World War, according to evidence uncovered by The Associated Press.

Michael Karkoc, 94, told American authorities in 1949 that he had performed no military service during the Second World War, concealing his work as an officer and founding member of the SS-led Ukrainian Self Defence Legion and later as an officer in the SS Galician Division, according to records obtained by the AP through a Freedom of Information Act request. The Galician Division and a Ukrainian nationalist organization he served in were both on a secret American government blacklist of organizations whose members were forbidden from entering the United States at the time.

Though records do not show that Karkoc had a direct hand in war crimes, statements from men in his unit and other documentation confirm the Ukrainian company he commanded massacred civilians, and suggest that Karkoc was at the scene of these atrocities as the company leader.

Nazi SS files say he and his unit were also involved in the 1944 Warsaw Uprising, in which the Nazis brutally suppressed a Polish rebellion against German occupation.

The U.S. Department of Justice has used lies about wartime service made in immigration papers to deport dozens of suspected Nazi war criminals. The evidence of Karkoc's wartime activities uncovered by AP has prompted German authorities to express interest in exploring whether there is enough to prosecute. In Germany, Nazis with "command responsibility" can be charged with war crimes even if their direct involvement in atrocities cannot be proven.

Karkoc refused to discuss his wartime past at his home in Minneapolis, and repeated efforts to set up an interview, using his son as an intermediary, were unsuccessful.

Efraim Zuroff, the lead Nazi hunter at the Simon Wiesenthal Center in Jerusalem, said that based on his decades of experience pursuing Nazi war criminals, he expects that the evidence showing Karkoc lied to American officials and that his unit carried out atrocities is strong enough for deportation and war-crimes prosecution in Germany or Poland.

"In America this is a relatively easy case: If he was the commander of a unit that carried out atrocities, that's a no brainer," Zuroff said. "Even in Germany … if the guy was the commander of the unit, then even if they can't show he personally pulled the trigger, he bears responsibility."

Former German army officer Josef Scheungraber -- a lieutenant like Karkoc -- was convicted in Germany in 2009 on charges of murder based on circumstantial evidence that put him on the scene of a Nazi wartime massacre in Italy as the ranking officer.

Could result in prosecution

German prosecutors are obligated to open an investigation if there is enough "initial suspicion" of possible involvement in war crimes, said Thomas Walther, a former prosecutor with the special German office that investigates Nazi war crimes.

The current deputy head of that office, Thomas Will, said there is no indication that Karkoc had ever been investigated by Germany. Based on the AP's evidence, he said he is now interested in gathering information that could possibly result in prosecution.

Prosecution in Poland may also be a possibility because most of the unit's alleged crimes were against Poles on Polish territory. But Karkoc would be unlikely to be tried in his native Ukraine, where such men are today largely seen as national heroes who fought for the country against the Soviet Union.

Karkoc now lives in a modest house in northeast Minneapolis in an area with a significant Ukrainian population. Even at his advanced age, he came to the door without help of a cane or a walker. He would not comment on his wartime service for Nazi Germany.

"I don't think I can explain," he said.

Members of his unit and other witnesses have told stories of brutal attacks on civilians.

Like a trance

One of Karkoc's men, Vasyl Malazhenski, told Soviet investigators that in 1944 the unit was directed to "liquidate all the residents" of the village of Chlaniow in a reprisal attack for the killing of a German SS officer, though he did not say who gave the order.

"It was all like a trance: setting the fires, the shooting, the destroying," Malazhenski recalled, according to the 1967 statement found by the AP in the archives of Warsaw's state-run Institute of National Remembrance, which investigates and prosecutes German and Soviet crimes on Poles during and after the Second World War.

"Later, when we were passing in file through the destroyed village," Malazhenski said, "I could see the dead bodies of the killed residents: men, women, children."

In a background check by U.S. officials on April 14, 1949, Karkoc said he had never performed any military service, telling investigators that he "worked for father until 1944. Worked in labor camp from 1944 until 1945."

However, in a Ukrainian-language memoir published in 1995, Karkoc states that he helped found the Ukrainian Self Defence Legion in 1943 in collaboration with the Nazis' feared SS intelligence agency, the SD, to fight on the side of Germany -- and served as a company commander in the unit, which received orders directly from the SS, through the end of the war.

It was not clear why Karkoc felt safe publishing his memoir, which is available at the U.S. Library of Congress and the British Library and which the AP located online in an electronic Ukrainian library.

Chance to confront

Karkoc's name surfaced when a retired clinical pharmacologist who took up Nazi war crimes research in his free time came across it while looking into members of the SS Galician Division who emigrated to Britain. He tipped off AP when an internet search showed an address for Karkoc in Minnesota.

"Here was a chance to publicly confront a man who commanded a company alleged to be involved in the cruel murder of innocent people," said Stephen Ankier, who is based in London.

The AP located Karkoc's U.S. Army intelligence file, and got it declassified by the National Archives in Maryland through a FOIA request. The Army was responsible for processing visa applications after the war under the Displaced Persons Act.

The intelligence file said standard background checks with seven different agencies found no red flags that would disqualify him from entering the United States. But it also noted that it lacked key information from the Soviet side: "Verification of identity and complete establishment of applicant's reliability is not possible due to the inaccessibility of records and geographic area of applicant's former residence."

Wartime documents located by the AP also confirm Karkoc's membership in the Self Defence Legion. They include a Nazi payroll sheet found in Polish archives, signed by an SS officer on Jan. 8, 1945 -- only four months before the war's end -- confirming that Karkoc was present in Krakow, Poland, to collect his salary as a member of the Self Defence Legion. Karkoc signed the document using Cyrillic letters.

Part of Poland

Karkoc, an ethnic Ukrainian, was born in the city of Lutsk in 1919, according to details he provided American officials. At the time, the area was being fought over by Ukraine, Poland and others; it ended up part of Poland until the Second World War. Several wartime Nazi documents note the same birth date, but say he was born in Horodok, a town in the same region.

He joined the regular German army after the Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941 and fought on the Eastern Front in Ukraine and Russia, according to his memoirs, which say he was awarded an Iron Cross, a Nazi award for bravery.

He was also a member of the Ukrainian nationalist organization OUN; in 1943, he helped negotiate with the Nazis to have men drawn from its membership form the Self Defence Legion, according to his account. Initially small, it eventually numbered some 600 soldiers. The legion was dissolved and folded into the SS Galician Division in 1945; Karkoc wrote that he remained with it until the end of the war.

Some cases won

Policy at the time of Karkoc's immigration application -- according to a declassified secret U.S. government document obtained by the AP from the National Archives -- was to deny a visa to anyone who had served in either the SS Galician Division or the OUN.

The U.S. does not typically have jurisdiction to prosecute Nazi war crimes but has won more than 100 "denaturalization and removal actions" against people suspected of them.

Department of Justice spokesman Michael Passman would not comment on whether Karkoc had ever come to the department's attention, citing a policy not to confirm or deny the existence of investigations.

Though Karkoc talks in his memoirs about fighting anti-Nazi Polish resistance fighters, he makes no mention of attacks on civilians. He does indicate he was with his company in the summer of 1944 when the Self Defence Legion's commander -- Siegfried Assmuss, whose SS rank was equivalent to major -- was killed.

"We lost an irreplaceable commander, Assmuss," he wrote about the partisan attack near Chlaniow.

Machine-gunning people

He did not mention the retaliatory massacre that followed, which was described in detail by Malazhenski in his 1967 statement used to help convict platoon leader Teodozy Dak of war crimes in Poland in 1972. An SS administrative list obtained by AP shows that Karkoc commanded both Malazhenski and Dak, who died in prison in 1974.

Malazhenski said the Ukrainian unit was ordered to liquidate Chlaniow in reprisal for Assmuss' death, and moved in the next day, machine-gunning people and torching homes. More than 40 people died.

"The village was on fire," Malazhenski said.

Villagers offered chilling testimony about the brutality of the attack.

In 1948, Chlaniow villager Stanislawa Lipska told a communist-era commission that she heard shots at about 7 a.m., then saw "the Ukrainian SS force" entering the town, calling out in Ukrainian and Polish for people to come out of their homes.

"The Ukrainians were setting fire to the buildings," Lipska said in a statement, also used in the Dak trial. "You could hear machine-gun shots and grenade explosions. Shots could be heard inside the village and on the outskirts. They were making sure no one escaped."

Memoir mentions location

Witness statements and other documentation also link the unit circumstantially to a 1943 massacre in Pidhaitsi, on the outskirts of Lutsk — today part of Ukraine — where the Self Defence Legion was once based. A total of 21 villagers, mostly women and children, were slaughtered.

Karkoc says in his memoir that his unit was founded and headquartered there in 1943 and later mentions that Pidhaitsi was still the unit's base in January 1944.

Another legion member, Kost Hirniak, said in his own 1977 memoir that the unit, while away on a mission, was suddenly ordered back to Pidhaitsi after a German soldier was killed in the area; it arrived on Dec. 2, 1943.

The next day, though Hirniak does not mention it, nearly two dozen civilians, primarily women and children, were slaughtered in Pidhaitsi. There is no indication any other units were in the area at the time.

Heorhiy Syvyi was a nine-year-old boy when troops swarmed into town on Dec. 3 and managed to flee with his father and hide in a shelter covered with branches. His mother and 4-year-old brother were killed.

Version involves Ukrainians

"When we came out we saw the smoldering ashes of the burned house and our neighbors searching for the dead. My mother had my brother clasped to her chest. This is how she was found — black and burned," said Syvyi, 78, sitting on a bench outside his home.

Villagers today blame the attack generically on "the Nazis" -- something that experts say is not unusual in Ukraine because of the exalted status former Ukrainian nationalist troops enjoy.

However, Pidhaitsi schoolteacher Galyna Sydorchuk told the AP that "there is a version" of the story in the village that the Ukrainian troops were involved in the December massacre.

"There were many in Pidhaitsi who were involved in the Self Defence Legion," she said. "But they obviously keep it secret."

Different story

Ivan Katchanovski, a Ukrainian political scientist who has done extensive research on the Self Defence Legion, said its members have been careful to cultivate the myth that their service to Nazi Germany was solely a fight against Soviet communism. But he said its actions — fighting partisans and reprisal attacks on civilians — tell a different story.

"Under the pretext of anti-partisan action they acted as a kind of police unit to suppress and kill or punish the local populations. This became their main mission," said Katchanovski, who went to high school in Pidhaitsi and now teaches at the University of Ottawa in Canada. "There is evidence of clashes with Polish partisans, but most of their clashes were small, and their most visible actions were mass killings of civilians."

There is evidence that the unit took part in the brutal suppression of the Warsaw Uprising, fighting the nationalist Polish Home Army as it sought to rid the city of its Nazi occupiers and take control of the city ahead of the advancing Soviet Army.

The uprising, which started in August 1944, was put down by the Nazis by the beginning of October in a house-to-house fight characterized by its ferocity.

Listed as lieutenant

The Self Defence Legion's exact role is not known, but Nazi documents indicate that Karkoc and his unit were there.

An SS payroll document, dated Oct. 12, 1944, says 10 members of the Self Defence Legion "fell while deployed to Warsaw" and more than 30 others were injured. Karkoc is listed as the highest-ranking commander of 2 Company -- a lieutenant -- on a pay sheet that also lists Dak as one of his officers.

Another Nazi accounting document uncovered by the AP in the Polish National Archives in Krakow lists Karkoc by name -- including his rank, birthdate and hometown -- as one of 219 "members of the S.M.d.S.-Batl 31 who were in Warsaw," using the German abbreviation for the Self Defence Legion.

In early 1945, the Self Defence Legion was integrated into the SS Galicia Division, and Karkoc said in his memoirs that he served as a deputy company commander until the end of the war.

Wife died in 1948

Following the war, Karkoc ended up in a camp for displaced people in Neu Ulm, Germany, according to documents obtained from the International Tracing Service in Bad Arolsen, Germany. The documents indicate that his wife died in 1948, a year before he and their two young boys -- born in 1945 and 1946 -- emigrated to the U.S.

After he arrived in Minneapolis, he remarried and had four more children, the last born in 1966.

Karkoc told American officials he was a carpenter, and records indicate he worked for a nationwide construction company that has an office in Minneapolis.

A longtime member of the Ukrainian National Association, Karkoc has been closely involved in community affairs over the past decades and was identified in a 2002 article in a Ukrainian-American publication as a "longtime UNA activist."