Home > Religious Affairs | Katriuk2012 | Video Links

Aljazeera | 22Nov2012 | Jill Emery and Jean Michel Carre  [47:29]

Ukraine: State of Chaos

Has the eastern European country been returned to the grips of the powerful oligarchs and neighbouring Russia?

Filmmakers: Jill Emery and Jean Michel Carre

Ukraine, the biggest country in Eastern Europe, is sandwiched between Russia and the West. It was a vital player in the downfall of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) in 1991.

And the Orange Revolution in 2004 ended the corrupt autocratic pro-Russian regime.

But six years later, through the newly elected President Viktor Yanukovich, the head of the Party of Regions, it returned to the grips of its powerful oligarchs and Russia. So the people got neither the rule of law nor the democracy they had imagined.

[W.Z. This documentary presents a brief history of Ukraine, comments by Viktor Yushchenko, Holodomor survivor, WWII, disillusionment with German "liberators",  return of Soviets, death of Stalin, Kuchma and Gorbachev comments on Chernobyl nuclear explosion. Disintegration of the Soviet Union as related by Natalia Changula and her mother -- human chain from Lviv to Kyiv (1990?), declaration of independence 24Aug1991, election of Kuchma and rise of Oligarchs, Yushchenko, Yulia Tymoshenko,  Gongadze death  and "Ukraine without Kuchma" campaign led by Yulia Tymoshenko, which led to reprisals against her family and her, nomination of Yanukovych as presidential candidate, poisoning of Yushchenko on 05Sep2004, Orange Revolution, Krivorizhstal reprivatization followed by dismissal of Tymoshenko as Prime Minister, Yanukovych becomes Prime Minister after 26Mar2006 parliamentary elections, Brian Bonner comments on Yulia Tymoshenko that she really tried to curb corruption, Medvedev visit to Ukraine, trials of Yulia Tymoshenko and her conviction on 11Oct2011, touching tribute by Natalia Changula to her recently deceased mother, Yaroslava Leshchenko.]

Filmmaker view:

By Jill Emery

It's terrible to lie in chains and rot in dungy deep,
But it's still worse when you are free,
To sleep and sleep and sleep.

(Taras Shevchenko, 1814-1861, a famous Ukrainian poet and author of the national anthem)

I visited Ukraine for the first time in 1963 on a school trip to Russia for pupils studying Russian in the UK. Ukrainian Nikita Kruschev had replaced Joseph Stalin at the head of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR).

Ukraine, at the western extremity, was not like Russia -- it seemed sunnier.

In the streets, young people gave us shy glances filled with curiosity, before lowering their eyes and hastening their pace. Talking to us meant danger for them. To them, we were from outer space - the enemy. But we soon found they were ready to take risks.

During our visit we were strictly controlled by our tourist guides. But at night we managed to escape their guard to meet two boys who had earlier thrown us a discrete ball of screwed up paper, which seemed to suggest a meeting place.

They were proficient in English, keen to know about the other side, rebellious, intelligent and curious. But they disappeared as soon as they heard the familiar sound of OGPU (secret police) officers nearby.

Unfortunately, Ukraine was another planet then, and to me it still is.

Ukraine has been shaped by centuries of invasion and today people of many different ethnic origins make up the population. The Ukrainians are an explosive, colourful, joyous people despite centuries of repression by big brother Russia. But the Orange Revolution was proof of what the people were capable of.

By the end of 2004, I returned to Ukraine with Jean-Michel Carre to start work on a film.

It was during this period that the revolution was fully underway in Ukraine. In the capital, Kiev, people thronged the streets, night and day, old and young, together, talking in groups about their revolution, their democracy. How proud and optimistic they were.

We felt that our own democracies had a bitter flavour, but these people were so positive, so sure. Why had the Orange Revolution taken place? What had led up to it? How was history responsible for the present? A film had to be made.

We continued to film over the next six years at parliamentary election times, meeting people in different towns and villages. Crossing the country on bumpy roads, we followed the relentless and glamorous Yulia Tymoshenko as she campaigned in Siberian weather, opened blocks of council flats or visited modest shops.

People threw themselves at her feet. She was the Ukrainian Evita Peron. President Viktor Yushchenko remained more discreet, patriotic but inefficient and - to most minds - seriously, physically and psychologically diminished by his infamous poisoning during the Orange Revolution.

In the interviews we obtained, he makes damning accusations against Russian President Vladimir Putin and speaks frankly of his hatred for Tymoshenko.
For the Ukrainian people, Yushchenko and Tymoshenko's "political divorce" after only months in office was the end of a soap opera dream and the beginning of the end.

It became clear that the country was still corrupt, the political infrastructure a mess, individual personalities too important and basic essentials still Soviet.

Today, Ukraine still seems so different from Russia. The "bandit state" created by serving President Viktor Yanukovich and his oligarch cronies is even worse than the one that preceded the Orange Revolution.

Since filming, one of our journalist's assistants became councillor for her village on the outskirts of Kiev. She created a petition to protect Kiev Forest from building developers affiliated with Yanukovich. But she has had to hire bodyguards to protect her and her family from the oligarch police.

Meanwhile, our co-producer, who is now campaigning in the elections, is under investigation for his role in our film.

I have also personally received an official legal summons in Ukraine to reveal how much money Tymoshenko's party allegedly paid me to make a film against the regime.

My only hope is that the new regime has gone too far this time and that the people will revolt once again.